It appears you have not yet registered with the DOG Forums. To register please click here...



Reply
 
LinkBack Thread Tools Display Modes
Old 02-19-2008   #1 (permalink)
GreedyBYB
Guest
 
GreedyBYB's Avatar
 
Posts: n/a
Cool I am a GreedyBYB

I have read so many posts where people bad mouth anyone who breeds dogs for profit I thought I would post a little info about what its like to BE a BYB and why I do it.

I am disabled with 6 herniated disc, degenerative joint disease, and diabetes. I am a single parent. I do not get disability, child support or any other means of income. I have tried everything to make money so that me and my son can live. I even had my electricity turned off in the middle of winter because I couldn't pay the bill and could get NO help anywhere and believe me I tried everything imaginable. NO ONE CARES. When you have a child to take care of you do what you have to do to take care of them. THAT is why I started raising dogs.

Now don't get me wrong. I LOVE my dogs. I take very good care of them. They are not caged, they live in the house with me and my son and have a huge 1/2 acre fenced yard to run and play in. I keep them wormed and vaccinated and don't sell my pups until they are 8 weeks old. They are all very well socialized and treated like family. I make them sweaters and bandanas to wear and they are very happy.

Everyone is so fast to condemn me for breeding dogs for a profit but every time I have puppies to sell, they all sell usually within 2 days of offering them because there are always people wanting to buy a puppy and no amount of bashing and badmouthing the breeder is going to make people stop buying puppies. Look at all the publicity out there right now about puppy mills yet that doesn't stop people from buying from them and it never will.

There is nothing you can say to me that will make any difference because bottom line is....I have to take care of myself and my son in the only way I know how. Period.

Last edited by GreedyBYB; 02-19-2008 at 08:20 PM. Reason: edited out a misleading typo.
 
Digg this Post!Add Post to del.icio.usBookmark Post in TechnoratiFurl this Post!
Reply With Quote
Old 02-19-2008   #2 (permalink)
Minn
Guest
 
Minn's Avatar
 
Posts: n/a
Default

There are so many dog's that need rescue. Thats where my problem is with breeding for profit. It's really selfish. And if you can breed and take care of puppies you can find a job. I can't beleive that selling dogs can bring in the kind of money to take care of a family. minn
 
Digg this Post!Add Post to del.icio.usBookmark Post in TechnoratiFurl this Post!
Reply With Quote
Old 02-19-2008   #3 (permalink)
GreedyBYB
Guest
 
GreedyBYB's Avatar
 
Posts: n/a
Default

Quote:
Originally Posted by Minn View Post
There are so many dog's that need rescue. Thats where my problem is with breeding for profit. It's really selfish. And if you can breed and take care of puppies you can find a job. I can't beleive that selling dogs can bring in the kind of money to take care of a family. minn

I only get enough to pay my electric and internet and buy a few necessities (toilet paper, soap cleaning supplies etc... and dog food/supplies). I don't have a car. I used to work for a veterinarian for years and can do most everything for my dogs that they need and have a very good veterinarian who works with me as far as payments etc should I need him for anything major. I only have a few dogs tho, nothing large scale. As far as my "being able to work if I can care for my dogs"....If you MUST know, not only do I have the problems listed in my first post but I am also incontinent of bowel AND bladder. I sit on a gardeners stool with wheels and scoot around to get things done. It is a struggle but I manage as I HAVE to. I have no choice. I would LOVE to have a work at home job over the internet etc but all that I have found ask for money to start and it is an established fact that is a SCAM. By all means, if you can hook me up with a legitimate work at home job that I can do here on my pc, feel free.

I agree with all of you as far as puppy mills go. They are horrible. They dogs are not cared for or socialized and disposed of without a second thought. They SHOULD be shut down. I love pets/animals of all kinds and if they aren't taken care of people shouldn't be allowed to have them.

I love my dogs. I truly do, they are my family, my friends, my companions. I love on my little puppies and treat them like my own babies and it is VERY hard to let them go when it is time to sell them. But I do it because I have to.
My son is begging me right now to keep a little tiny male puppy that he just adores but I can't, that puppy will pay my electric bill for one month. Sad, but true.

Last edited by GreedyBYB; 02-19-2008 at 11:47 AM.
 
Digg this Post!Add Post to del.icio.usBookmark Post in TechnoratiFurl this Post!
Reply With Quote
Old 02-19-2008   #4 (permalink)
simbasdog
Guest
 
simbasdog's Avatar
 
Posts: n/a
Default

i really cant believe this post,it almost feels as a windup,much like the posters name.
i think this poster should be more specific and go into more detail on the breed,breeds used, how often are the dogs bred , are they registered,and also the temperament and physical values of the sire and dam ie ,breed standard.
 
Digg this Post!Add Post to del.icio.usBookmark Post in TechnoratiFurl this Post!
Reply With Quote
Old 02-19-2008   #5 (permalink)
GreedyBYB
Guest
 
GreedyBYB's Avatar
 
Posts: n/a
Default

Quote:
Originally Posted by simbasdog View Post
i really cant believe this post,it almost feels as a windup,much like the posters name.
i think this poster should be more specific and go into more detail on the breed,breeds used, how often are the dogs bred , are they registered,and also the temperament and physical values of the sire and dam ie ,breed standard.
What difference does it make really? I breed for money. Regardless of what type breed, registration, etc....In YOUR eyes I am nothing but a Greedy BYB, thus, my screenname. I am not stupid. I knew before I posted what kind of reaction people like YOU would give. It's no windup. It's a FACT. All of you always are quick to bash, flame and judge people when they post asking valid questions. I have gone back through the postings and seen questions asked where NOT ONE OF YOU bothered to answer. Well, since you obviously get your kicks by sitting there all high and mighty, flaming others who don't live life to YOUR standards, here is your chance to flame away at someone who couldn't care less. Knock yourself out. Bottom line is, like the people I tried getting help from who didn't care....I no longer care. I will do whatever I have to do to raise my child. It's as simple as that. Take it how you want to.

Last edited by GreedyBYB; 02-19-2008 at 05:08 PM.
 
Digg this Post!Add Post to del.icio.usBookmark Post in TechnoratiFurl this Post!
Reply With Quote
Old 02-19-2008   #6 (permalink)
Minn
Guest
 
Minn's Avatar
 
Posts: n/a
Default

No one called you stupid, and you are Greedy admitted by yourself. Ask a question and I am sure we will answer. But using dogs as ho's to make money when you can work, really is not cool. There are to many dog's that need homes,why create more. And like I stated before I can't believe you make enough to raise a family. Do you check out these buyers, do you go to there homes, references etc? If you love these puppies it's the least you could do. And if you do then you can find a job. I will not respond to anymore of your post. I find it pointless. Minn
 
Digg this Post!Add Post to del.icio.usBookmark Post in TechnoratiFurl this Post!
Reply With Quote
Old 02-19-2008   #7 (permalink)
GreedyBYB
Guest
 
GreedyBYB's Avatar
 
Posts: n/a
Default

Quote:
Originally Posted by Minn View Post
No one called you stupid, and you are Greedy admitted by yourself. Ask a question and I am sure we will answer. But using dogs as ho's to make money when you can work, really is not cool. There are to many dog's that need homes,why create more. And like I stated before I can't believe you make enough to raise a family. Do you check out these buyers, do you go to there homes, references etc? If you love these puppies it's the least you could do. And if you do then you can find a job. I will not respond to anymore of your post. I find it pointless. Minn

Actually I didn't admit anything about being greedy, I read through all your the posts here on this forum and saw that term thrown around alot in reference to anyone who breeds for profit. I breed for profit so therefore, I must be greedy right? Of course forget the fact that I take good care of my dogs and see to their needs and health. Forget the fact that if I chose to, I could breed on a large scale and make a lot more money,yet I choose to only make enough to get the necessities of life. No frills, no splurging. I just want to take care of myself and my son. There are a lot of dogs and puppies that need good homes yes, as there are cats, horses, you name it.

What prompted me to post in the first place was when reading through posts here from other people asking questions and seeing harsh rude answers such as "If you have to ask that question, you have no business breeding" etc... really irks me. Everyone has to ask questions and learn, even the experts didn't know ANYTHING until they researched and asked questions and educated themselves, which is what people come here to try and do and instead get flamed and bashed because they want to be a dog breeder. You mean if you are not already an EXPERT dog breeder then you can't learn to be one? Give me a break.

You start out small, you take baby steps and you learn the basics. It is a learning experience and you NEVER learn it all. Even the EXPERTS don't know it all. No one does. How can people sit there behind a computer screen and put down others and bash them when they have the RIGHT to pursue whatever hobby or career they choose to do?

People have the RIGHT to live their life the way they choose. Personally, I care more about stopping this...Children for sale - Dateline NBC - MSNBC.com
and this....Global Sex Slavery
than I do stopping people from breeding dogs or any other animal.
If people spent their time and energy on stopping things like that instead of sitting online bashing people for what they do for a living, they just might be able to make a difference in the life of a child who desperately needs it. The world is a horrible place.
 
Digg this Post!Add Post to del.icio.usBookmark Post in TechnoratiFurl this Post!
Reply With Quote
Old 02-19-2008   #8 (permalink)
Moderator
Best In Show
 
Yogi's Avatar
 
Join Date: Mar 2007
Location: Lake Stevens, WA
Posts: 1,856
Thanks: 0
Thanked 12 Times in 8 Posts
My Mood: Busy
Yogi is on a distinguished road
Default

I am not agreeing or disagreeing for your reason for breeding but I do take question at your remark that you have 6 herniated discs, degenerative joint disease and diabetes and you claim you cannot get any financial support but food stamps. It is a fact that if you live in the US you are eligible for Welfare from you local state in addition due to the fact that you have an illness or disease that will prevent you from working substantially for at least a year your are eligible for SSI (Social Security Supplememtal Insurance). This is tax payor paid program subsidized by the govt and not to be confused with Social Security Full term disability. For you to be receiving food stamps implies that you must have some source of income which if you listed this income as your dogs and sale of puppies which puts your income below a certain level than I am confused as you state that due to no income you are a breeder and this is the only reason you are. Yet if you are not breeding for the income than there is no reason you would not qualify for the program noted.
The discs in my back are not herniated but are in fact degenerative, in addition to my shoulder joints. Cardiac patient as well as diagnosed with neuropathy and rheumatoid arthritis. I worked for myself so when the Dr told me I could no longer work I had no choice but to file for welfare and at that time they started the process for my SSI which is currently being processed.
I am in fact a breeder though hardly anymore. I was one for over 47 years and did not make a dime doing so as the cost of real care for my dogs and the offspring basically covered their expenses. On average I was left owing my vets from $1.k to $2.k a year. These days the ones I have are predominately rescues less a couple breeders. Too young at this point and to be truthful I do not know with my medical condition if I will consider it again.
__________________
No I am not a Miniature Doberman, I was around 200 years before Karl Frederich Louis Doberman created the Dobie, and as for my friends the Manx cats, yes they are better at playing fetch than I am, I am a Miniature Pinscher. http://blackhawkkennels.webs.com/
Yogi is offline  
Digg this Post!Add Post to del.icio.usBookmark Post in TechnoratiFurl this Post!
Reply With Quote
Old 02-19-2008   #9 (permalink)
GreedyBYB
Guest
 
GreedyBYB's Avatar
 
Posts: n/a
Default

Quote:
Originally Posted by Yogi View Post
I am not agreeing or disagreeing for your reason for breeding but I do take question at your remark that you have 6 herniated discs, degenerative joint disease and diabetes and you claim you cannot get any financial support but food stamps. It is a fact that if you live in the US you are eligible for Welfare from you local state in addition due to the fact that you have an illness or disease that will prevent you from working substantially for at least a year your are eligible for SSI (Social Security Supplememtal Insurance). This is tax payor paid program subsidized by the govt and not to be confused with Social Security Full term disability. For you to be receiving food stamps implies that you must have some source of income which if you listed this income as your dogs and sale of puppies which puts your income below a certain level than I am confused as you state that due to no income you are a breeder and this is the only reason you are. Yet if you are not breeding for the income than there is no reason you would not qualify for the program noted.
The discs in my back are not herniated but are in fact degenerative, in addition to my shoulder joints. Cardiac patient as well as diagnosed with neuropathy and rheumatoid arthritis. I worked for myself so when the Dr told me I could no longer work I had no choice but to file for welfare and at that time they started the process for my SSI which is currently being processed.
I am in fact a breeder though hardly anymore. I was one for over 47 years and did not make a dime doing so as the cost of real care for my dogs and the offspring basically covered their expenses. On average I was left owing my vets from $1.k to $2.k a year. These days the ones I have are predominately rescues less a couple breeders. Too young at this point and to be truthful I do not know with my medical condition if I will consider it again.
Let me rephrase that...I USED to get food stamps. I couldn't get any help and started breeding dogs and no longer get them. A misleading typo on my part, my apologies. Nice they started SSI for you, in my state they do NOTHING to help you. You have to do it all yourself and I am working on that. Meanwhile we have to eat and have electricity......

I don't expect anyone to agree with me, I just wanted to make it known what circumstances prompted me to be a breeder, sometimes it's not a question of greed, it's a question of survival.

Last edited by GreedyBYB; 02-19-2008 at 08:37 PM.
 
Digg this Post!Add Post to del.icio.usBookmark Post in TechnoratiFurl this Post!
Reply With Quote
Old 02-29-2008   #10 (permalink)
Bobbijean
Guest
 
Bobbijean's Avatar
 
Posts: n/a
Default Greedy BYB

Your first and foremost responsibility is to you and your child. And nobody has the right to tell you how to do it.

I know how you feel I breed to pay the dogfood bill. and for fun. and sometimes to pay the gas bill.

I applaud the fact you can do something to help you and your family. Listening to you, it is obvious to me you care about your animals and are not a mill.

Take care of yourself

Bobbi:mrgreen:
 
Digg this Post!Add Post to del.icio.usBookmark Post in TechnoratiFurl this Post!
Reply With Quote
Old 02-29-2008   #11 (permalink)
Poohbear
Guest
 
Poohbear's Avatar
 
Posts: n/a
Default

Wow! Sorry, I disagree! I want a true breeder to care about the breed. That said, I hope that you would try.

I can understand that you would try for money, but you should try, even trying for money, to make the breed better.

My boy, Rex came from a puppy mill, he is an excepcianall (sp) dog. I was lucky.

Now, that I know better, I think that I want a better breeder.
 
Digg this Post!Add Post to del.icio.usBookmark Post in TechnoratiFurl this Post!
Reply With Quote
Old 03-03-2008   #12 (permalink)
DogandBigCatMama
Guest
 
DogandBigCatMama's Avatar
 
Posts: n/a
Default

Sounds to me like YOUR the judgmental one. Sounds to me like you feel the need to defend yourself before anyone says anything to you because deep down you feel guilty. Why else would you start such a thread? I read through this whole thing and it just made me roll my eyes and laugh.
 
Digg this Post!Add Post to del.icio.usBookmark Post in TechnoratiFurl this Post!
Reply With Quote
Old 03-03-2008   #13 (permalink)
nattiej1976
Guest
 
nattiej1976's Avatar
 
Posts: n/a
Default

Quote:
Originally Posted by DogandBigCatMama View Post
Sounds to me like YOUR the judgmental one. Sounds to me like you feel the need to defend yourself before anyone says anything to you because deep down you feel guilty. Why else would you start such a thread? I read through this whole thing and it just made me roll my eyes and laugh.


I with you on that one..........This is no more than forum Trolling at its best!
 
Digg this Post!Add Post to del.icio.usBookmark Post in TechnoratiFurl this Post!
Reply With Quote
Old 03-11-2008   #14 (permalink)
whatsup00
Guest
 
whatsup00's Avatar
 
Posts: n/a
Default

I also breed dogs. I might earn enough from it to buy my kids some of the extra stuff that they like or to pay a few bills. I say earn because to be a good breeder is alot of work and I feel like I earn that money the same as someone who works outside the home. My husband works outside the home and provides a good income for us, however my puppy money has helped with those extras. I clean kennels, water bowls, food dishes, groom, and play with my dogs on a daily basis. I clean puppy pens and change papers many times throughout the day with litters of puppies. It is alot of work. Not to mention weeding through puppy buyers to make sure my puppies get good homes. I might mention all of my puppies are generally sold within a week of advertising them. Most have deposits on them at 2 weeks of age and homes waiting for them at 8 weeks. I have a stipulation in my contract that if the new owners cannot keep their puppy/dog it comes back to me, none of my dogs will end up in the pound.
I am sure I am going to hear about the already overpopulated dog world. Well, here is my take on it. Most of the dogs in our local pound are large to med mixed breeds. It is not breeders who are overpopulating the dog world. It is the irresponsible PET owners who allow their dogs to breed with the mutt down the road because they are to lazy and cheap to have their pet sterilized.
That being said I am sure I will get bashed. And that's ok. Everyone has their own opinion. I do not believe in nasty puppymills who keep their dogs in substandard conditions. I do however believe in the right to breed dogs. And if the AR's are allowed to have their way it will be illegal in a few years to breed dogs. So those of you who spout that dog breeding should be illegal, all dog breeders are bad etc etc etc, where are you going to get your next puppy from? 10 yrs down the road there may be no puppies to buy. If breeding purebreds is illegal then surely irresponsible owners will also need to have their pets fixed, thus ending the overpopulation problem. So where will puppies come from?
 
Digg this Post!Add Post to del.icio.usBookmark Post in TechnoratiFurl this Post!
Reply With Quote
Old 03-11-2008   #15 (permalink)
Senior Member
Working Dog
 
mightymite's Avatar
 
Join Date: Aug 2007
Posts: 170
Thanks: 0
Thanked 0 Times in 0 Posts
mightymite is on a distinguished road
Default

I am not here to bash anyone. I have, what you might call, a "well balanced" perspective on this. I worked for a vet and for the North Shore Animal League as a kid. I have been in and around breed rescue my entire life, I also show and train dogs and many of my closest friends are "show dog" people.

Dog breeding, in of itself, is not bad! When done properly, it is a service to all of us! What would happen if, as those on the far extremes of Animal Rights would have it, all dogs were spayed and neutered and no dog breeding was allowed? ("One Generation and out"). Domesticated dogs would be eradicated and all our lives would be far less rich as a result. Dog breeders have a very important role to play in society and our economy. We all owe ethical, hard working breeders a debt of gratitude for the sleepless nights and the huge vet bills. However, it is a definite misconception that all those dogs in shelters that are being euthanized are 1) mixed large breed dogs and 2) products of "opps" breedings. BYB's are the #1 source of dogs feeding the pet overpopulation problem, with puppy millers and opps breedings following thereafter. Interestingly, the dogs that are being euthanized are primarily young dogs, not puppies. Behavioral problems are the major reason for abandonment. Which brings me to my next point:

It's not breeding that is bad, it's breeding dogs who should not be bred. Behavioral problems, just like health problems, have two components - nature and nurture. I am also a member of APDT and do a lot of in-home pet consultations and training. I have seen puppies purchased from pet shops and BYBs, raised by loving families who started training early, and yet, clearly these puppies had deep seated behavioral problems. The problem with breeding for profit is that your decision to breed two dogs together can be swayed by the financial gain over other important criteria. If you are hard up on money, I have to assume that such tests that only a vet can do such as CERF and PENNHIP are not being performed. You may also choose to breed whatever stud you own to whatever bitch you own – without regard to how the dogs structures would blend or how distant or how closely related they are, or generally, what kind of puppy will result from the combination of the dam and sire’s traits. These are hypothetical’s – but based on the facts as have been presented in this thread. The sad truth is many of the problems, including hip displasia and adult aggression, may not surface until the dog is well past puberty and in his new home. He, thusly, becomes the new owner’s problem. “Educated” dog people by in large buy dogs from experienced breeders, it’s the people who are not “dog educated” that are more likely to run to buy a puppy from an ad in the newspaper or a pet shop. So they are far less equipped to handle these problems as they come up. Even if the breeder offers “full money guarantee” for the first 30 days, the doesn’t help when the problem surfaces at a year and half! Thus, it is at that point, that the owner gives up the young dog to rescue or shelters and the problem of homeless pets continue.

There was a post just recently on my own message board. Someone wanted to know if two dogs that don’t get along could be bred. The male was actually being aggressive to the female. Aside from the fact that the dogs were mixed breed dogs and the owner clearly didn’t know what genetic issues were in their backgrounds, it was kind of mind boggling that she would even attempt such a breeding considering that the male had obvious behavioral problems. Was this something she really wanted to have passed down to another generation of puppies?

One more thing, it is a complete fallacy that small dogs do not wind up in shelters. I have rescued at least four Yorkies from my town shelter in the past year. PURE BRED Yorkshire Terriers (or at least three Yorkies and what was probably a purebred Silky Terrier). As I am writing this, I am sitting next to a Yorkie who came from a shelter (yes, he had behavioral problems). I also had another Yorkie growing up whose original owner wanted her euthanized because she had no bite inhibition. When Maggie bit – she bit to break skin and god did she have a temper!. Yet, I don’t believe she was abused. She came to us with a beautiful pink bow in her hair and a hand crocheted blankie. Someone loved her dearly – but couldn’t handle her. In desperation, she thought euthanasia was the last resort. Being “Dog people” we took her in and she lived with us until the ripe old age of 15. She was lucky we were there – but it is not fare to think that there will always be a family equipped to deal with a dog that will bite and scar other people! How many people are there out there who are willing to take on such a liability? Whenever Maggie was handled by a vet or groomer she always had to be muzzled . . . you can image the difficulties we had with her as she got older and needed more critical medical care!
mightymite is offline  
Digg this Post!Add Post to del.icio.usBookmark Post in TechnoratiFurl this Post!
Reply With Quote
Old 03-11-2008   #16 (permalink)
whatsup00
Guest
 
whatsup00's Avatar
 
Posts: n/a
Default

I said the majority of dogs in our local shelter are mixed large breed dogs. I am sure there are a fair number of small breeds that come in to shelters. But the large to med mixed breeds outnumber them by far. And you cannot lay the blame for temperment problems at the feet of the breeders alone, the owners share the blame.
So you assume that because I am not a show breeder and that I make some profit by breeding dogs that I do not do proper health testing or take my dogs in for vet care? You assume wrong. Doing the neccesary health tests and ensuring that my dogs are healthy only makes my puppies more valuable. Why would I not do it? I agree that dogs with temperment problems should not be bred. My dogs are bred to produce pets. Most of the people who want one of my puppies have children. Breeding dogs with temperment problems would also give myself and my breed a bad rep. Why would I do that?
I love my breed. Because I choose not to show does not mean that I should not breed if I can produce nice healthy puppies. I do all of the same testing that show breeders do (some show breeders do no testing). My pups come back to me if they need rehomed. I feel like I am doing everything right. If I am termed a BYB then I guess I am proudly a BYB
 
Digg this Post!Add Post to del.icio.usBookmark Post in TechnoratiFurl this Post!
Reply With Quote
Old 03-11-2008   #17 (permalink)
Senior Member
Working Dog
 
mightymite's Avatar
 
Join Date: Aug 2007
Posts: 170
Thanks: 0
Thanked 0 Times in 0 Posts
mightymite is on a distinguished road
Default

Please don't be so defensive and please do read what I wrote carefully.

First, I said that it is a fallacy that there are no small dogs in shelters. I did not speak to the percentages. However, keep in mind that breed rescue comes in and takes the majority of small dogs out of shelters - because they do so poorly in the shelter environment. Also many people will rush to adopt a small dog (even people who are generally afraid of dogs) even if that particular small dog is not a good fit in their homes. There’s a lot more “circulation” of small dogs in and out of the system as a result. If you want a better understanding on why there it appears as though big dogs out number small dogs in shelters - get your hands on Sue Sternberg's video on small dog adoptions. She goes into detail on why shelter employees need to get little dogs out of shelters and into foster care ASAP. My own little guy stopped eating for two days and was so distressed, the shelter employees put him in the back away from the adoption area during the time he was at a shelter. One other point Sue makes, people put up with a lot more from little dogs than they do with big dogs. A small dog who bites may be tolerated where a big dog would be put down.

Second, I did not blame breed and temperament problems on breeding alone – I said it was mix of nature and nurture. However, quite to the contrary, too often the owners are blamed for failing to train or mistreating the dog in some way. Being a professional dog trainer, I can tell you that I have seen dogs who are trained and cared for right from the start but have deep seated temperament problems due to poor breeding. Breeders must step upto the plate and take responsibility for the temperaments they passed down through their lines. No manner of good training will change a dogs basic temperament. An overly soft dog may be more likely to bite out of fear aggressive tendencies and an overly condident/dominant dog may be more likely to bite out of assertiveness and dominance based aggression. It’s the breeder’s responsibility to cull such dogs out of their breeding program. Which begs the question – if you have only a couple of dogs to breed from and you’re livelihood depends on the generation of more and more puppies – what’s the incentive?

Second, my comment about health testing was directed to the original poster on this board who said she had little money and did most of the medical care herself. Please re-read her post and then read mine.

Now, while I did not make any direct comparison between show breeders and bybs in my post - as you insinuated - I'll say this:

When I look at a good breeder, I look for someone who has a dedicated interest in his/her dogs and not just for monetary gain specifically because of all the reasons I have already cited. Someone who does "stuff" with her dogs - be it conformation, or performance (hunting for example) or companion events (agility, flyball, disc dog, etc) will always be my first choice in a breeder. I use it as a litmus test of the structural integrity of her dogs and the health of her breeding program. These are dogs who cannot break down or else they cannot perform the tasks that are being asked of them. Any dog, even one who is sickle hocked and displastic, can sit on a sofa and be the family pet - but only a sound dog can race through a flyball jump grid and slam himself into a flyball box. The dog fancy is a small enough place that if a breeder was consistently producing unsound dogs, people would notice as their dogs would be breaking down over the course of years. Again, keep in mind that duration was another key point in my post - it's one thing to hand someone a puppy and say "yep, I did my testing and nothing came up and this puppy has all his shots." That may hold true for a year - maybe two or three. However, we are finding that many genetic defects (such as PRA for example) come out later in life - a breeder who is dedicated to developing a line of "FILL IN THE BLANK" dogs, needs to keep careful record of these sorts of things - over the course of YEARS - long after the initial sale. So yes, while I did not say it in my post - I would say that I have a bias for what you would call "show breeders." They are breeding for a standard of performance and structure which mitigates the economic standard (and no, I don't have rose colored glasses on this - many show breeders domake considerable money breeding dogs). It's a question though that their reputations are on the line and their dogs are an on-going project for them. Each litter has to be an improvement on what came before it because of the competitive standard that they are working towards As a byb - you just don't have the same incentives. Sorry.

The proof is in the pudding. I see many "yorkies" in my neighborhood. These dogs are clearly the product of byb and pet shop breeding. The sloppy breeding that went into these dogs is evident just from a cursory look - ears that don't stand up, wooly coats, too big, too small, sickle hocked, runny eyes, collapsed trachea - if a dog is sold as a Yorkie but does not look like a Yorkie - what is the point of buying said "purebred dog"? And if the breeder can't even take enough care to make sure that the dog they are selling looks like what he is proported to be, what are the chances that same breeder is going to make sure that what can't be seen such as latent genetic defects, are also being screened? Slim to none.

Last edited by mightymite; 03-11-2008 at 03:46 PM.
mightymite is offline  
Digg this Post!Add Post to del.icio.usBookmark Post in TechnoratiFurl this Post!
Reply With Quote
Old 04-10-2008   #18 (permalink)
dolcechihuahua
Guest
 
dolcechihuahua's Avatar
 
Posts: n/a
Default Tired of preaching...

This thread may be old but after reading through it, I felt the need to speak my mind. I've spent a lot of time on different pet/dog forums...while I'm new to this forum I'm not new to the controversial subject on BYB and breeding dogs in general.

Before I go into my whole schpeal - I did want to say a little bit about myself...considering I'm new to this forum. I've loved animals my entire life, and now that I'm able have made it a point to make as big a difference in the animal community as possible. Last year I rescued 12 cats and kittens, and one APBT all out of my apartment. I own one beautiful APBT of my own, and have been very involved in anti BSL and raising my pitty as an ambassador of the breed. While Pit Bulls are my LOVE, I only have the one - finding housing with a Pit Bull is damn near impossible unless you're trying to live in the ghetto. (Around here anyways). It always breaks my heart to see people breeding Pit Bulls for profit, not spaying and neutering when SO MANY end up euthanized, and in shelters - unadoptable? Mainly because nobody can find an insurance company that will cover a home housing a Pit Bull, and there are no apartments that will allow an obvious Pit Bull to reside there - consider yourself lucky if your Pit Bull is the result of poor breeding and looks like it could be a lab mix. While Pit Bulls are my breed, I would NEVER breed, or condone the breeding of Pit Bulls/Staffys that aren't registered, show quality animals. There's just too many to validate adding more pet quality animals.

That said, I'm also the owner of two Chihuahuas. I must say having small dogs is MUCH more convenient, and easy. I've also found, landlords LOVE to hear you've got Chihuahuas. They'd much rather have a tiny dog living in their space then a large Pit Bull. My Chihuahuas come from a local breeder. Funny - I searched online everywhere for a chihuahua to rescue in my area...I got three results on Pet Finder and none of the Chihuahuas would fit into my home. Either they weren't good with cats, weren't good with other dogs, or had health issues and needed medication daily.

I AM considering breeding my AKC female Chihuahua. I've come to realize that MANY many people want Chihuahuas. They're the ideal dog for most living situations, low maintenance, small, inexpensive to feed (compared to a large dog), and easy to take to and from. Not everybody has $1000+ to spend on a Chihuahua from champion show dog lines - and that's for a pet quality Chihuahua on a spay/neuter contract. Could somebody explain to me, if there's no Chihuahuas to adopt in the shelters (and NEVER Chihuahua puppies, YES some people would prefer to raise their dog from puppy hood) and the only available Chihuahuas are RIDICULOUSLY expensive...how is the average person, on an average income supposed to afford that as well as veterinary expenses?

Also...'professional' show breeders are so quick to bash anybody that has questions about breeding, or that show interest in starting to breed - where did they start I'd like to know? These people wouldn't have questions if they had MENTORS, professional breeders mentoring new breeders..now there's an idea.

I'm not defending OP as I don't really know them, and don't know what kind of dogs they're producing, or what breed of dogs...I do however get a little bit tired of the preaching from people doing the same thing...breeding dogs. There are responsible pet breeders, there are show breeders, and there are BYB. I've seen pet quality, and show quality dogs in shelters. JUST my opinion.

Just my piece...I in no way condone people mass producing dogs, mistreating their breeding dogs, breeding genetic faults, breeding breeds that are overpopulating the shelters, breeding dogs that don't fit into the breed standard even remotely, breeding teacups, minis, or 'designer' dogs and breeding mix breed dogs...I do however think that the term Back Yard Breeder is thrown at people who are doing nothing more than offering the average family a pet quality, healthy, genetically sound but not SHOW QUALITY animal for a reasonable price.

Last edited by dolcechihuahua; 04-10-2008 at 03:16 PM.
 
Digg this Post!Add Post to del.icio.usBookmark Post in TechnoratiFurl this Post!
Reply With Quote
Old 07-23-2008   #19 (permalink)
muff0808
Guest
 
muff0808's Avatar
 
Posts: n/a
Default Obama and mccain bandanas!!!

Okay, I know this is off-topic, but I love this site and we were talking about bandanas:
The Dog Vote | Obama dog bandanas, McCain dog bandanas | Give your dog a vote!

Get your dog a bandana to show off your political colors (or theirs, i guess?!)
 
Digg this Post!Add Post to del.icio.usBookmark Post in TechnoratiFurl this Post!
Reply With Quote
Old 07-23-2008   #20 (permalink)
Bearded Lady
Guest
 
Bearded Lady's Avatar
 
Posts: n/a
Default

Well spare me the sob story. What relevance your life circumstance has to dog breeding is none. I also don't care if you make a profit for breeding dogs. The question, really, is what type of product are you selling to ignorant dog buyers. If someone is willing to pay a higher margin for a healthy lifelong companion dog is of no importance to me or anyone on this forum. But if you're producing crap and telling us your sob story for sympathy, believe me, you won't find me knocking at your door for a pup. I'm not that ignorant, and excuse us for trying to educate those who are about people who produce crappy dogs. Your suffering is not even on the same scale as the suffering dog buyers have when their poorly produced dogs get sick or are ill tempered. No, the world doesn't revolve around you, and BYB will always be a four letter word in my book. And yes I am this callous.
 
Digg this Post!Add Post to del.icio.usBookmark Post in TechnoratiFurl this Post!
Reply With Quote
Reply



Tags
abused , adding , afraid , animals , apartment , art , back , bad , begging , bite , bite inhibition , breeder , breeding , breeds , cats , choice , choose , conformation , diabetes , disc , disease , dog , dog food , dogs , dogs and puppies , emergency , family , find , flyball , food , foster , groomer , guess , hair , happy , hobby , housing , hunting , ice , issues , kids , kind , laws , lol , love , magazine , mixed breed dogs , money , neuropathy , owners , pets , problem , problems , products , puppies , puppy , puppy mills , pups , questions , registered , rescue , road , run , sale , seeking , show dog , support , talk , talking , toilet , treat , vet , veterinarian , what breed


Thread Tools
Display Modes

Posting Rules
You may not post new threads
You may not post replies
You may not post attachments
You may not edit your posts

BB code is On
Smilies are On
[IMG] code is On
HTML code is Off
Trackbacks are On
Pingbacks are On
Refbacks are On



All times are GMT -4. The time now is 10:52 PM.




SiteMap:1 2 3 4 5 6 7 8 9 10 11 12 13 14 15 16 17 18 19 20 21 22 23 24 25 26 27 28 29

I am a GreedyBYB