[indiandog]

What is the best way to train a dog? Using treats or using toys? What to do when the dog is not doing what you want the dog to do? I am just curious and want to get some opinions.

[myca]

I used simple way in training my dog. Food is best way to make them follows command. If my dog behaves well I let him choose the best food for him. But if he disobey me, I'm giving him only bones to play. It's simple but effective way.

[BiggerDog]

Both have their advantages, use what will motivate your dog the best. Then use it to reward your dog when he/she does what you ask (only when). Starting with frequent rewards for little successes then moving on to multiple commands for a reward. This way the dog doesn't start to rely on the treat.

--BiggerDog

[granma_ota]

It is mainly dependent upon the dog. Suki always wanted to play fetch with her squeaky toy. My Coco is definately food-motivated though a retreiver roll will work, too. Molly wants her belly rubbed. Abraham wants to play tug of war and get a hug. Cubby is a praise-and-scratch dog. And Maggie . . . . . . . . well, I think Maggie is a cat disguised as a dog.

For bad behaviors, a spray bottle of water is the most effective tool that I have found.

[SeeSpotRun]

The spray bottle or just general scolding works well for punishments. Treats are really effective as a reward for good behavior.