When he uses the bathroom in the house i put his nose in it and tell him no!! and then take him straight outside. Rathering than punishing him and spanking him. I was doing that from the get go but Im just tired of doing that.

Don"t Beat Them When They Do Wrong It' S Best To Build A Bond Between The Pet And Owner. The More You Hit Them The Closer You Are To Making Them Vicious. So Love Your Pet.

If you don't have a pet order nutrolizer, to spray over that area then it will keep doing it over and over no matter how much disapline you give. The scent must be completly gone... Remember they have a stong sense of smell so make sure you don't just use soap and water to clean it up. You are doing a good job of reinforcment.